The Born Good Podcast
A brand's soul is not an abstract ideal or an empty purpose pledge. It's your company's true story made manifest through everything you sell, say and do. We provide the rigor to help you find, tell and manage it as you grow.
Learn More
The Born Good Podcast
The Dangers of Sanding Your Brand’s Sharp Edges
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode explores how growing brands often lose their unique identity by trying to appeal to a broad, mainstream audience. The hosts argue that the "sharp edges" of a company are exactly what foster intense customer loyalty. When leadership uses focus groups and committees to remove controversial elements, they inadvertently trade passionate advocates for indifferent consumers. This process of seeking broad acceptance often results in a bland, forgettable brand that struggles to compete against generic alternatives. Ultimately, brands must resist corporate conformity and remain polarizing to maintain their creative energy and market relevance. True long-term success comes from deepening a specific niche rather than smoothing over the characteristics that first made the brand special.
So I want you to picture a brand that you discovered maybe um a few years ago. Right. Like maybe it was this super hyper-specific skincare line or a really rugged outdoor apparel company or even just an independent coffee roaster.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. Everyone has one of those.
SPEAKER_01Right. And think about what it felt like when you first found them. The packaging was probably a little weird. Maybe the typography was super aggressive. And the product itself just had this really distinct, uncompromising point of view.
SPEAKER_00It felt special.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Buying it felt like you were in on a secret. You told your friends about it, you advocated for it, you basically made a part of your personality.
SPEAKER_00Yep. You joined the club.
SPEAKER_01But then fast forward to today, that exact same brand is sitting on the shelf of some massive big box retailer, and the packaging is suddenly this very safe, minimalist pastel situation.
SPEAKER_00And the weird typography is totally gone.
SPEAKER_01Totally gone. Replaced by a generic corporate font. I mean, the product works fine, sure, but it feels completely hollow now, uninspired, just, you know, safe.
SPEAKER_00It's a tragedy we see all the time.
SPEAKER_01It really is. And welcome to the Born Good Podcast, by the way. Today we are taking a deep dive into this massive paradox about growth, success, and human attention.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell It's a huge topic.
SPEAKER_01It is. We're going to unpack the hidden machinery behind why trying to be broadly appealing, like playing it safe to capture the masses, is actually the most dangerous thing a growing business or even an individual can do.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Because the underlying mechanics of that transition, they're incredibly consistent across almost every industry you look at. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, a brand usually starts out solving a very specific problem for a very small group of people, people who felt completely ignored by the mainstream market.
SPEAKER_01They are the outsiders.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. So the creators build something unusual, they speak in a distinct voice, and they're rewarded for it. But the moment that success hits a certain threshold, the corporate machine kind of takes over.
SPEAKER_01And the pressure mounts.
SPEAKER_00The pressure mounts to abandon the exact traits that made them special to begin with. So the core thesis we're looking at today goes against almost every traditional corporate instinct, which is this human attention actually requires contrast. Contrast. The moment you smooth yourself out to please everyone, you make it mathematically and psychologically impossible for anyone to actually love you.
SPEAKER_01Man, that is that's intense. But to really understand the systemic failures that happen later on, I feel like we need to establish the psychology of that early success first. Because those first customers, they aren't just conducting a financial transaction, right? When a product caters so specifically to a niche high-friction preference, the customer is essentially buying identity.
SPEAKER_00They're buying identity, yes. It feels like stumbling into a secret club.
SPEAKER_01Right. And identity signaling is basically the engine of that early growth.
SPEAKER_00It is. Because when a group feels misunderstood or ignored by the broader market, and then a company comes along and speaks directly to their weird specific preferences.
SPEAKER_01It's magic.
SPEAKER_00It's magic. The friction of finding and adopting that product is actually a feature, not a bug. They don't just consume it quietly.
SPEAKER_01No, they won't shut up about it.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. They become evangelists. They tie a piece of their own personal identity to the success of this product. And that devotion is high friction, but it's high reward.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell But and here's where the problem starts: that friction is exactly what outside capital hates.
SPEAKER_00Oh, they desmise it.
SPEAKER_01Right. Because the inevitable trajectory is that venture capital arrives. Or maybe the founders just look at their initial success and suddenly the growth targets multiply.
SPEAKER_00The spreadsheet takes over.
SPEAKER_01The spreadsheet takes over. And this quiet, incredibly dangerous shift in mandate takes place behind closed doors. The goal basically shifts from serving the tribe to capturing the vast middle of the market.
SPEAKER_00And the strategic conversations completely change. The leadership team starts pulling up these demographic charts, and they're asking, well, how do we sell this exact same item to college students and corporate executives and retirees and soccer moms, all at the exact same time.
SPEAKER_01Which sounds impossible.
SPEAKER_00Because it is. The mandate shifts from depth of connection to just breadth of distribution.
SPEAKER_01Okay, let's unpack this from the perspective of a founder, though, or a board member. Because I get it, the underlying logic feels irresistible.
SPEAKER_00It's very seductive.
SPEAKER_01It's like when an underground punk band signs to a major label, right? And suddenly they release a polished pop album. If you have proven that you can sell to 10,000 passionate weirdos, why wouldn't you just tweak the formula slightly, just polish the sharp edges a bit to sell to 10 million ordinary people?
SPEAKER_00Right. Because the math looks absolutely flawless on a spreadsheet. 10 million casual buyers obviously generate more revenue than 10,000 fanatics.
SPEAKER_01It's just basic arithmetic.
SPEAKER_00But the flaw is in assuming that human behavior scales linearly without changing the nature of the product. Because to reach 10 million people, a company has to ensure they do not bother anyone. Right. They have to remove literally any element that requires context or patience or just a specific taste. And that is exactly when the sanding down begins.
SPEAKER_01So the business basically takes a piece of sandpaper to its own identity. But I'm curious, what are those edges, practically speaking? Because you know, sharp edges sounds a bit abstract, but it represents very tangible choices that a company is making every day.
SPEAKER_00Well, an edge is basically anything that forces a reaction.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00So it could be an eccentric, sarcastic sense of humor in their marketing emails, or it could be a highly aggressive visual style.
SPEAKER_01Like hot pink and skulls or something.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Or it could be a really controversial, firm stance on an industry practice. Or even just refusing to compromise on a high price point because you demand high quality.
SPEAKER_01Right, like refusing to use cheap materials.
SPEAKER_00Right. And those are the exact reasons the first crowd fell in love. Yeah. Give them something firm to grab onto. But in the quest for mass appeal, those edges are suddenly reclassified by the boardroom as hazards.
SPEAKER_01Total liabilities.
SPEAKER_00Liabilities. Leadership starts panicking about risk mitigation. They wonder uh, is this joke going to alienate conservative shoppers, or is this packaging too weird for a standard supermarket shelf?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell So to mitigate that risk, leadership usually turns to the ultimate corporate safety net, right? The committee and the focus group.
SPEAKER_00The dreaded focus group.
SPEAKER_01Because if the goal is to avoid bothering anyone, you just ask a bunch of strangers what bothers them, and then you systematically remove it.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And the psychology of the boardroom at this stage is entirely driven by loss aversion. I mean, executives will routinely risk losing 10 fanatic customers just to avoid a single negative comment from a total stranger.
SPEAKER_01It's wild.
SPEAKER_00It is wild. So let's break down the mechanics of a focus group when they're presented with a truly bold, original idea.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it.
SPEAKER_00Imagine you put 10 random people in a room and you show them something with those sharp edges we talked about. Statistically, two people will fiercely love it. Two people will violently despise it.
SPEAKER_01And the rest.
SPEAKER_00The remaining six will probably just be confused.
SPEAKER_01So the data comes back showing polarization. Half the room either hates it or just doesn't get it at all.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Now compare that to showing those exact same ten people a generic pastel-colored idea.
SPEAKER_01Oh boy.
SPEAKER_00Soft fonts, polite words, completely inoffensive. Nobody in that room gets angry.
SPEAKER_01But nobody loves it either. It just kind of exists.
SPEAKER_00Right. It just exists. But the committee, watching from behind the two-way mirror, they do not care about the lack of love. They are optimizing for a lack of anger.
SPEAKER_01That is such a huge distinction.
SPEAKER_00It changes everything. They mark the pastel concept down as a safe choice. And step by step, the company replaces everything memorable with something sterile. The copywriting becomes polite and bland. The design mimics every other competitor in the aisle.
SPEAKER_01And any controversial opinions just vanish into safe corporate platitudes about like quality and community.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Corporate speak.
SPEAKER_01But wait, let me push back for a second. Isn't the entire point of market research and consumer data to find out what people actually want?
SPEAKER_00You would think so.
SPEAKER_01Right. Because if we're arguing that listening to consumer consensus actually makes products worse, that feels like a total rejection of data-driven business altogether.
SPEAKER_00Well, focus groups and consensus data are highly effective tools, but only if your goal is to discover what nobody actively hates.
SPEAKER_01Ah.
SPEAKER_00They measure tolerance, not desire. The problem is that human attention does not function like a spreadsheet. We do not notice things simply because they are broadly acceptable.
SPEAKER_01We filter them out.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. The cognitive science behind attention relies on the brain's reticular activating system, which actively filters out mundane, safe, predictable information just to conserve mental energy. We only pay attention when something has contrast, a distinct shape, a really unique point of view.
SPEAKER_01It's like camouflage. If you paint yourself to look exactly like the background environment, you really can't be surprised when consumers just walk right past you.
SPEAKER_00That's a great way to put it. In a market that's drowning in infinite options, the absolute worst thing you can be is pleasant and harmless.
SPEAKER_01Pleasant and harmless.
SPEAKER_00Because harmless things blend directly into the background wallpaper of daily life. When a brand sands down its edges so that nobody can possibly dislike it, they inherently make it impossible for anyone to love it.
SPEAKER_01So if our brains are biologically filtering out these safe products, how does that translate when someone is actually standing in the grocery aisle holding their wallet? Because eventually, you know, a purchase has to happen. Right. This invisibility isn't just a philosophical problem. It has to hit the bottom line.
SPEAKER_00Oh, the financial consequences are absolutely brutal because love requires commitment, and commitment requires taking aside.
SPEAKER_01Okay, say more about that.
SPEAKER_00Let's consider the hot sauce principle. Imagine a company makes a hot sauce that tastes like pure fire and vinegar. It is incredibly intense.
SPEAKER_01My stomach hurts just thinking about it.
SPEAKER_00Right. Most shoppers walking down the aisle will hate it. Some might even find the smell offensive just opening the bottle.
SPEAKER_01So that is a highly polarizing, very sharp-edged product. You are intentionally alienating probably 80% of the grocery store.
SPEAKER_00But and here is the key. The fanatics who crave that intense flavor aren't just buying a bottle once a year. They will buy a case every single month.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they're obsessed.
SPEAKER_00They wear the brand's t-shirt. They go to their local diner and harass the owner until they start carrying that specific sauce. They are fiercely loyal because the brand took a side and gave them exactly what they wanted.
SPEAKER_01But then the venture capital comes in or the growth mandate hits.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. And the data shows that 80% of shoppers think the sauce is way too spicy or too acidic.
SPEAKER_01So the logical corporate move is to sweeten it. You water it down to capture that 80%.
SPEAKER_00Yep. And you might convince a few casual shoppers to pick it up on a whim. It's agreeable now, it's pleasant.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But in doing so, you completely betray the fanatics who put you on the map to begin with.
SPEAKER_01You destroy the secret club.
SPEAKER_00You destroy it.
SPEAKER_01So by trying to win everyone, you literally trade loyal advocates for indifferent consumers.
SPEAKER_00It's a terrible trait.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell, but put yourself in the shoes of a founder for a second, right? Someone with a mortgage and a payroll to meet. It is terrifying to intentionally let a customer walk right past your product. Like we are biologically wired for social inclusion. We want people to like what we do.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell It goes against all of our evolutionary social conditioning. I mean, it feels deeply unnatural to watch someone reject your work when you have the power to change it to please them.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00But the most enduring, valuable businesses understand that they must decide who they are for, and just as importantly, who they are explicitly not for.
SPEAKER_01Who they are not for.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Being polarized into the outside world is the mandatory price of admission for deep devotion on the inside.
SPEAKER_01And the economics of that trade-off swapping fanatics for casuals, they're entirely different, right? Because a casual shopper isn't going to advocate for you.
SPEAKER_00Not at all. The casual shoppers who buy the watered down sweetened hot sauce do not care about the brand whatsoever. The minute another sweet mild sauce goes on sale for 50 cents cheaper, they will abandon the product without a second thought.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_00When a company sands down its edges to compete on mass appeal, they lose all their pricing power. They're no longer selling an identity. They're selling a commodity. You have zero loyalty because you stand for nothing.
SPEAKER_01That is such a stark reality check. You literally trade a customer who will fight for you for a customer who will leave you for 50 cents.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01But this obsession with broad appeal, it doesn't just destroy the product on the shelf. The hidden machinery of this paradox actually destroys the company from the inside out, doesn't it? There is a massive cost to the internal culture of the business.
SPEAKER_00Oh, this is the internal rot that rarely gets discussed in traditional business case studies.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because when a brand has a strong, polarizing point of view, coming to work feels meaningful for the employees. They take immense pride in making something with character.
SPEAKER_01They care about the details.
SPEAKER_00They'll stay late and argue passionately over the smallest things, a single line of copy, a specific shade of color, because those details actually matter to the identity of what they're building.
SPEAKER_01But when the mandate shifts to, you know, offend no one and fit in everywhere, the psychological environment of the office has to completely change.
SPEAKER_00The energy evaporates overnight. I mean, you cannot be passionate about beige.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You cannot be passionate about a pastel-colored, committee-approved platitude. The daily work shifts from asking, how do we make this incredible? to asking, how do we ensure legal doesn't flag this? Or will this offend a suburban demographic?
SPEAKER_01It just sounds exhausting.
SPEAKER_00It is. The work turns into standard defensive corporate management.
SPEAKER_01And that's when the talent drain starts, isn't it? Yep. Because the creative thinkers, the eccentrics, the people who actually built the sharp edges in the first place, they look around and realize their unique skills, are now considered a liability by the leadership team. So they just leave.
SPEAKER_00And when the creatives leave, you really have to look at who replaces them.
SPEAKER_01Who is it?
SPEAKER_00They're replaced by caretakers.
SPEAKER_01Caretakers, wow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, caretakers are not there to build a secret club or disrupt an industry. They are administrators. They are perfectly comfortable managing a slow, steady decline. Their entire job is to optimize the supply chain and maintain the sanded down, ineffensive status quo.
SPEAKER_01It is exactly like a sports team shifting from a strategy of playing to win to just playing not to lose. The passion just dies on the field, and you are literally just running out the clock until the inevitable end.
SPEAKER_00Because true growth never comes from smoothing yourself out until you mimic every generic legacy player on the market. If you are a challenger brand and you start copying the giant, boring corporations you originally set out to disrupt, you surrender your only advantage.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Long-term survival requires going deeper into the exact things that made you different to begin with.
SPEAKER_01It is entirely counterintuitive because if you reach a stage where you need to scale, the instinct is to turn the volume down, to round off the corners so more people can hold it.
SPEAKER_00And you have to fight that instinct with everything you have. The world already has enough safe, quiet, forgettable products. The groceryals are full of them, the app stores are full of them. Our brains are actively filtering them out.
SPEAKER_01So the takeaway for you listening to this deep dive today is pretty clear. Keep your sharp edges, keep your opinions. Do not be afraid to let a large group of people walk away completely unimpressed or even slightly annoyed by what you do.
SPEAKER_00Let them walk away.
SPEAKER_01Right, because the people who do stick with you will love you for it. And as we've seen, that resulting love, that irrational fanatic devotion is the only thing that actually protects a business, granting pricing power and longevity over the long run.
SPEAKER_00It is the ultimate defense mechanism against a highly competitive market. You know, we've spent this entire deep dive talking about venture capital and brands and hot sauce. I want to leave you with a thought that brings this much closer to home. Think about your own career. Okay. Think about your own personality and how you navigate your professional life. In your constant effort to be agreeable and perfectly professional and universally liked by everyone in your network, are you accidentally sanding down the very sharp edges of your own character? Oh wow. By trying so hard not to bother anyone in your office, are you making yourself completely invisible and therefore entirely replaceable?
SPEAKER_01Man, that completely flips the script. Are you making yourself invisible by trying to be universally acceptable? It is a heavy question to chew on, but understanding the mechanics of how attention and loyalty actually work gives you the power to change it. Thank you for joining us on this deep dive on the Born Good podcast. We will catch you next time.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The WARC Podcast
WARC
Uncensored CMO
Jon Evans
On Strategy Showcase
Fergus O’Carroll